I watched two coworkers react completely differently to the same feedback. What usually matters more?

Our manager gave nearly identical constructive feedback to two people this week. One thanked him and started making changes immediately. The other looked discouraged for the rest of the day. It made me wonder what really determines how we receive criticism.

Poll ended

Final Results

This poll has ended. Voting and comments are closed. Voting closed on Oct 13, 2026.

✓ 2 registered
● 2 total votes
50% voted How it's delivered
♛ How it's delivered 50%
1 vote
Who it's from 0%
0 votes
Our own confidence 0%
0 votes
Timing 0%
0 votes
♛ Past experiences 50%
1 vote
Save Message

Reasons & Discussion

No discussion yet

No discussion was added before voting closed.